Also, rather than presenting a survey of philosophical ideas presented through the lens of its topic, The Virtues of Captain America has a specific focus: I had several goals in mind as I wrote this book: Similar to the approach of the Blackwell Philosophy and Popular Culture series, in this book I introduce basic concepts of moral philosophy, especially virtue ethics, using examples drawn from decades of Captain America stories. In particular, I wanted to address the complexity of moral decision-making, for which simple rules, formulas, and virtues can be a guide but never the final answer.
Several books and movies have helped shape my world-view, and several others have at least helped me understand things I otherwise would not have known.
Since this post was originally way too long, I decided to break it into two sections so you would actually have time to read it. After a group of young, rash superheroes who happen to star in a reality TV show attempt to apprehend a group of supervillains goes horribly wrong, and an elementary school is destroyed, public outcry leads the US government to pass a bill requiring all super-powered individuals to register their secret identities and powers with the government and act as a sort of super police force.
The pro-registration side led by Iron Man feels that this is a natural progression of things and it is pointless to oppose that level of public uproar. As the fight wages on, Iron Man obtains funds from Congress to build a giant prison in the Negative Zone.
The purpose of this prison is to indefinitely house those superheroes that refuse to register without trial. This leads to an escalation in the conflict, which in turn leads to a no holds barred fight between the two sides.
Now that we have an extremely brief, mostly spoiler-free synopsis of Civil War I want to look at the two philosophies that I think best represent both sides. By understanding these two different ethical outlooks we might better understand why each side thinks they are making a moral choice.
Instead, what makes a particular action right or wrong is judged by the amount of good e. To make it even simpler, the end justifies the means. Age of Ultron as well. He is so set and so focused on this being the moral choice that he ignores the other Avengers and develops the technology in secret ultimately leading to Ultron, an enemy set on eradicating the human race.
Tony is a narcissist, which inherently leads to narcissistic utilitarianism, meaning he might not see the greatest good the same way someone with a different starting point would.
The greatest good for the greatest number sounds pretty great in theory, but like Communism there are definitely some flaws with this philosophical stance, and these deficiencies are clearly seen in real life and in the story of Civil War.
For instance, utilitarianism could be used to justify the slavery of a small group because it could bring happiness and economic stability to a greater number; or it could be used to justify imprisoning superheroes in the Negative Zone without a trial.
Both of these actions especially the one that actually exists in the real world would be considered wrong by most, but could be justified using a utilitarian point of view.Captain America is one of the many, many patriotic superheroes created during World War II to bolster morale on the home front, but none have lasted as long, been as influential, became as famous, or transcended their original time better than him.
The American Enlightenment was a period of intellectual ferment in the thirteen American colonies in the 17th to 18th century, which led to the American Revolution, and the creation of the American Republic. Captain America: The United States versus Itself, Through the Eyes of a Wartime Fictional Hero: Christian Dailly shows how the changing incarnations of the comic-book hero from his beginnings as the all-American hero in the struggle against Nazism in to the troubled and reflective warrior in the post 9/11 era, have reflected America’s changing views of their own society and its place in.
Jan 01, · The first look at the philosophy behind the "Captain America" comics and movies, publishing in advance of the movie release of "Captain America: The Winter Solider" in April In "The Virtues of Captain America," philosopher and long-time comics fan Mark D.
White argues that the core principles 4/5. After the close of the World War II, 24 senior leaders of the Einsatzgruppen were prosecuted in the Einsatzgruppen Trial in , charged with crimes against humanity and war crimes.
Fourteen death sentences and two life sentences were handed out. Which best embodies the American values: Superman, or Captain America?
Answer Wiki. 6 Answers Superman and Captain America almost equally represent American Values, but Captain America stands up for America better.
He then goes to lead America through World War II. Captain America embodies the American Dream. Unknown to.